Woman’s Mesothelioma Claim Against J&J’s Talc Manufacturer to Continue
When Lita Goldstein was diagnosed with malignant mesothelioma, she quickly realized that the only possible place she could have been exposed to asbestos was in the Johnson & Johnson talc products she’d used throughout her life. She filed suit against dozens of companies associated with the iconic consumer product, and one of them — talc manufacturer Kolmar Laboratories — filed a motion for summary judgment, asking for the case against them to be dismissed.
Talc Manufacturer’s Justification for Removal from Mesothelioma Claim Rejected
Kolmar Laboratories offered two different theories for why it shouldn’t have to defend itself against Ms. Goldstein’s mesothelioma claim. The first was that the victim had failed to offer proof that she’d been exposed to any talc product that they’d manufactured. The second was that despite having previously confirmed its manufacturing role in the product, as well as its active role in manufacturing the talc for Johnson & Johnson, they were simply following the company’s orders and should not be held liable for the outcome.
In response to these arguments, Justice Adam Silvera of the Supreme Court of New York County denied the motion. He explained that in order for a defendant to be dismissed from a mesothelioma claim, they needed to prove that there was no way that their product could have been responsible for the plaintiff’s illness. Because the company had focused on what they viewed as shortcomings in the plaintiff’s claim, they fell short of that requirement.
Judge Denies Defendant’s Contractor Defense in Mesothelioma Claim
As to the other argument offered by the mesothelioma defendant, Justice Silvera largely ignored the company’s “contractor’ defense that it was only following Johnson & Johnson’s orders and specifications. His ruling against their motion for summary judgment means that the case will move forward in New York’s court system for a jury to hear unless Kolmar and the plaintiff agree to a settlement beforehand.
FREE Financial Compensation Packet
- Info on law firms that will recover your HIGHEST COMPENSATION
- Learn how to get paid in 90 days
- File for your share of $30 billion in trust funds
